Flat Feet (Hindfoot Instability / PTTD)

Flat feet developing in adulthood are most often the result of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction (PTTD) — gradual weakening of the tendon that supports the arch, leading to progressive flattening and a distinctive pattern of hindfoot instability. This is a different condition to the flexible flat feet many people have had since childhood, and typically requires active management rather than simple observation.

What causes flat feet in adults?

The posterior tibial tendon runs behind the inside of the ankle and plays the primary role in supporting the arch during walking. As it weakens or tears — most often through gradual degeneration rather than a single acute injury — the arch loses its principal support and begins to flatten, and the heel gradually rolls outward, a pattern known as hindfoot instability. This differs mechanically from flexible flat feet present since childhood, which typically involve normal tendon function and rarely progress or cause significant problems.

 

PTTD explained

PTTD progresses through recognised stages: early tendon inflammation with a flexible, still-correctable flat foot; progression to a fixed flatfoot deformity as the tendon fails further; and, in advanced disease, secondary arthritis developing in the surrounding hindfoot joints as they absorb the abnormal load of a collapsed arch over an extended period. In the most advanced stage, the altered alignment can eventually affect the ankle joint itself, which is why the condition is best addressed while still in an earlier, more flexible stage. Identifying which stage a patient has reached is the single most important factor in determining appropriate treatment, since earlier stages respond far better to non-surgical measures than advanced, rigid deformity.

 

Symptoms

  • Pain and swelling along the inside of the ankle, particularly with activity
  • A gradual visible flattening of the arch
  • The heel appearing to roll or angle outward when viewed from behind
  • Difficulty walking on uneven ground as the deformity progresses
  • In advanced cases, pain shifting to the outside of the ankle as the hindfoot alignment changes further
  • A noticeable change in shoe wear patterns, with faster wear on the inside edge of the sole

 

Causes and risk factors

Adult-onset flat feet most commonly result from gradual degeneration of the posterior tibial tendon, influenced by age, body weight, inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, and previous injury to the tendon that was not fully treated at the time. It typically affects one foot more than the other, a pattern that helps distinguish it clinically from the flexible, usually symmetrical flat feet some people have had their whole lives.

 

How it is diagnosed

Clinical examination assesses arch position, tendon strength through resisted movement testing, and hindfoot alignment viewed from behind. Weight-bearing X-ray assesses the degree of deformity and identifies any developing arthritis in the hindfoot and midfoot joints; MRI is occasionally used to directly assess the condition of the tendon itself where the diagnosis or stage is unclear.

 

Non-surgical management

  • Custom orthotics or a supportive ankle-foot brace — supports the arch and reduces strain on the tendon
  • Physiotherapy — strengthens the tendon and surrounding muscles to support the arch actively
  • Activity modification — reducing load on the tendon during the acute inflammatory stage
  • Anti-inflammatory medication — for symptomatic flares

 

When surgery is considered

Surgery is considered when the deformity becomes rigid, or when non-surgical treatment no longer adequately controls symptoms. Surgical reconstruction aims to restore the arch and stabilise the hindfoot, with the specific procedure matched to the stage of deformity and detailed on the corresponding procedure page.

Frequently asked questions

What causes flat feet to develop in adults?

Most commonly, gradual weakening or tearing of the posterior tibial tendon, which normally supports the arch. This is influenced by age, body weight, inflammatory conditions, and prior injury to the tendon.

Do flat feet need surgery?

Not necessarily. Early-stage posterior tibial tendon dysfunction, while the deformity remains flexible, often responds well to orthotics, bracing, and physiotherapy. Surgery is considered when the deformity becomes rigid or non-surgical measures no longer control symptoms.

 

Noticed your arch gradually flattening?

Book an assessment with Mr Schneider to establish the stage of the condition and the most appropriate treatment path.