Surgical correction of a hammer toe is matched to whether the deformity is still flexible or has become fixed and rigid, since the two require fundamentally different techniques to achieve a straight, comfortable toe.
For a flexible hammer toe, a tendon transfer redirects one of the toe's own flexor tendons to work as an extensor, actively holding the toe straight using the body's own tissue rather than an implant. For a rigid hammer toe, where the joint itself has stiffened into the deformed position, a small portion of bone is removed from the affected joint (an arthroplasty) or the joint is fused in a straight, corrected position, directly addressing the bony contracture that a soft-tissue procedure alone cannot correct.
Surgery is considered once a hammer toe becomes rigid and no longer responds to footwear changes and padding, or earlier where pain and callusing are significantly affecting daily life despite consistent non-surgical care.
Soft-tissue correction versus bony correction
The flexible-versus-rigid distinction, established on examination before surgery, determines the entire surgical approach. A tendon transfer alone is sufficient for a genuinely flexible deformity, preserving the joint and its natural movement. Where the joint is rigid, addressing the bone itself is unavoidable — either removing a small segment of joint surface to allow the toe to sit straight (arthroplasty), or fusing the joint outright with a small internal wire or implant, chosen according to the severity of the contracture and whether adjacent toes are also involved.
Lesser toe surgery is typically performed as a day procedure under regional or local anaesthesia with light sedation. Operating time is generally short, often well under an hour, though this varies if multiple toes are corrected at the same time.
Recovery timing depends on whether a soft-tissue or bony correction was performed:
First 2 weeks
A stiff-soled post-operative shoe protects the toe, with a temporary wire (if used) typically removed at around 3 to 4 weeks.
By 6 weeks
Swelling has generally settled substantially and most patients are back in wider, comfortable regular footwear.
3 months
Continued gradual improvement in swelling and toe position, with the corrected alignment well established.
These are general ranges based on typical healing timeframes, not guarantees. Recovery depends on the specific procedure performed and individual healing.
General surgical risks include infection and delayed wound healing. Procedure-specific risks include residual stiffness at the corrected joint, over- or under-correction of the toe position, and recurrence of the deformity over time, particularly where an underlying contributing factor such as a bunion isn't addressed at the same time.
Most patients return to normal, comfortable footwear within 6 weeks. Return to higher-impact activity is guided by individual progress and comfort.
The goal of surgery is a straight, comfortable, functional toe, and this is achieved in the large majority of cases. Some minor residual stiffness at the corrected joint is common and generally doesn't affect function.
A temporary wire is used in some rigid-deformity cases to hold the toe in corrected position while it heals, and is removed in a simple in-rooms procedure a few weeks after surgery. Not every case requires one.
Not sure whether your hammer toe is flexible or rigid?
See The Hammer Toes condition →
Book a consultation with Mr Schneider to establish the right technique for your specific deformity.