A hammer toe is a deformity in which one of the smaller toes — most often the second — bends abnormally at its middle joint, producing a claw-like shape. Left untreated, the flexible early deformity can progress to a fixed, rigid position, and the change in shape frequently brings painful corns and callusing as a secondary problem in its own right.
A hammer toe develops when the tendons controlling extension and flexion of a lesser toe fall out of balance, causing the toe to buckle downward at its middle (proximal interphalangeal) joint while the base of the toe extends upward. The deformity most commonly affects the second toe, in part because it is frequently the longest toe and bears disproportionate pressure within standard footwear, though any of the lesser toes can be affected, and more than one toe is often involved on the same foot.
In its early stages, the deformity is flexible — the toe can still be manually straightened, and the joint retains normal passive movement. Left unmanaged, the deformity can progress to a fixed, rigid position in which the joint itself has stiffened into the abnormal shape, a distinction that meaningfully changes what treatment can achieve.
Hammer toe deformity arises from an imbalance between the muscles and tendons that flex and extend the toe, most commonly triggered or accelerated by footwear that crowds the toes into a narrow or tapered toe box. Structural factors also contribute meaningfully: a second toe that is naturally longer than the big toe is more prone to impingement within standard shoes, and an existing bunion frequently pushes the second toe out of its normal position, initiating or worsening a hammer toe on the same foot. Less commonly, underlying neurological or muscular conditions disrupt the normal balance of tendon function. Tight, narrow, or high-heeled footwear does not cause the underlying imbalance in isolation, but reliably accelerates its progression and is often the reason symptoms first become noticeable.
Diagnosis is primarily clinical. Examination establishes whether the deformity is still flexible — meaning the toe can be manually straightened and the joint retains passive movement — or has become fixed and rigid, since this distinction is the principal factor determining whether non-surgical management remains appropriate. Weight-bearing X-ray is used where there is uncertainty about joint involvement, associated forefoot deformity such as a bunion, or when surgical planning is being considered.
Surgery is considered once a hammer toe becomes rigid and no longer responds to footwear changes and padding, or earlier if pain and callusing are significantly limiting daily activity despite consistent non-surgical care. Whether the deformity is flexible or rigid at the time of assessment is the principal factor determining which surgical technique is appropriate — ranging from a soft-tissue release and tendon transfer for a flexible toe through to fusion of the affected joint for a rigid one — detailed on the corresponding procedure page.
A muscle and tendon imbalance within the toe, frequently triggered or worsened by footwear that crowds the toes, a naturally longer second toe, or an existing bunion pushing the neighbouring toe out of alignment.
In the early, flexible stage, footwear changes, splinting, padding, and orthotics can often manage symptoms and slow progression, though they do not reverse the underlying deformity. Once the toe becomes rigid, non-surgical measures manage discomfort but can no longer straighten it — surgical correction becomes the effective option at that stage.
Considering surgery, or want to understand what’s involved?
See The Lesser Toe Surgery →
Book an assessment with Mr Schneider to establish whether the deformity is still flexible, and the most appropriate way to manage it.